ERISA-Compliant Top Hat Claims in Alabama

If your employer offers a Top Hat plan as part of a qualified retirement plan, it’s important to understand your top hat status and what this means for your benefits package. At Sinclair Law, our team offers the experience and dedication to ensure you receive the compensation you were promised. Keep reading to learn more about this type of benefit plan.

What Is a Top Hat Claim?

A Top Hat claim is a specific category of employee benefit plans defined under Section 201(2) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA). These plans are established and maintained by employers primarily as a deferred compensation plan for a select group of key employees, typically management or highly compensated employees. It is important to note that top hat plans are exempt from some specific requirements of ERISA, such as rules concerning minimum participation, distribution, minimum funding, and fiduciary standards.

Additionally, these types of plans are not obliged to adhere to the requirement of holding plan assets in a trust. To qualify for these exceptions to ERISA claims procedures, your employer’s plan must meet each of the following requirements. The plan must be unfunded, meaning it is supported by the general, attachable assets of the corporation rather than a dedicated trust. The plan must also show a clear purpose for deferred compensation and must be limited to a select group of employees.

Are You the Type of Employee That Belongs in Top Hat Plans?

While the U.S. Department of Labor hasn’t provided a specific definition for employees eligible for a top hat plan, it has clarified the qualities these top-hat-eligible employees typically possess. The department emphasizes that top hat plan participants are generally employees in higher-ranking positions or with compensation levels that grant them significant influence over the design and execution of their deferred compensation plans. This means that these individuals may not require the full range of rights and protections provided by ERISA.

When determining whether employees fall within the top hat plan category, courts will often consider several factors. These include the percentage of the total workforce invited to join the plan, the nature of their employment duties, the difference in compensation between top hat members and non-members, and specific language articulated in the plan agreement. Eligibility for a top hat plan can be complicated and considers various factors such as organizational influence, employment responsibilities, compensation level, and your plan’s explicit terms. If you have questions concerning your top hat status, we recommend contacting your plan administrator for further clarification.

Why Is It Important Whether Your Plan Is Treated As a Top Hat Claim?

Whether your benefits plan is treated as a top hat plan carries significant implications. This is particularly true when it comes to the actions taken by your employer relating to the top hat plan that might otherwise be considered breaches of ERISA. A telling example of this is the recent case of Precious Plate, Inc. v. Russell. During this case, an executive filed a lawsuit against his employer, alleging a breach of fiduciary duty concerning a split-dollar insurance plan. The court found that the plan qualified as a top hat plan under ERISA and resulted in the immediate dismissal of the breach of fiduciary duty claims without further deliberation.

This case emphasizes that top hat plans are exempt from ERISA’s substantive requirements because Congress deemed top-level management to be appropriately capable of safeguarding their own pension expectations. This showcases the importance of understanding the classification of your benefits plan, as it not only shapes the regulations but also influences the potential legal consequences for employer actions related to your plan.

Why Would Anyone Want an Unfunded Plan Subject to the Company’s General Creditors?

An unfunded top hat plan is a valuable and sought-after element of a compensation package that serves as a powerful tool to motivate and retain a select group of management employees within the organization. The primary appeal of an unfunded structure comes from its exemption from ERISA Title I provisions when compared to a funded plan. ERISA requirements mandate that non-qualified deferred compensation plans must avoid discrimination, and opting for an unfunded approach allows executives to navigate these requirements with more flexibility.

Additionally, the unfunded nature of the plan alleviates beneficiaries from immediate tax obligations when sufficient funds are allocated for their benefit. This aspect not only provides executives with a more tax-efficient arrangement but also contributes to the plan’s attractiveness. Typically offered with the company’s qualified plans, top hat plans allow executives to defer income without being bound by regular benefits limitations.

Is There an Administrative Burden & Is Any Filing Required for a Top Hat Plan?

As far as administrative burdens, top hat plans are exempt from many ERISA requirements. This can include eligibility, notice, vesting, and participation requirements. Your company has the authority to determine who qualifies for top hat plans, so it’s essential to connect with your plan administrator to ensure you have the correct information concerning your eligibility. We also offer years of experience in filing top-hat claims, and our team is available to help through each step of this process.

Additionally, top hat plans do not require annual report filing. This differs from a qualified plan or nonqualified plans that do not meet the requirements of a top hat plan. These types of plans must complete a one-page notice filed with the US Department of Labor within 120 days of creation.

^{No representation is made that the quality of legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers. This website and the information contained herein have been prepared by and are the trademark property of Sinclair Law Firm, LLC, and are not authorized for dissemination or use by other parties. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. This information is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute a lawyer-client relationship. If you contact us by email, please be aware that communications through this website may not be privileged or confidential as e-mail is not secure.}